Life & fun · alternatives · 2026

24 alternatives to The Arbor House Treasury of Horror and the Supernatural

A must-read collection of bone-chilling horror stories.

Below are 24 products that do a similar job, ranked by how close each is in meaning and then by launch-day votes. The Arbor House Treasury of Horror and the Supernatural launched in 2016; newer entries below may have overtaken it.

1. 1
   Salem's Lot▲71

   An American horror story

   2015 · amazon.co.uk · its alternatives →

2. 2
   Scream▲56

   Chilling adventures in the science of fear

   2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

3. 3
   Bone Rooms▲73

   From scientific racism to human prehistory in museums

   2016 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

4. 4
   The Monocle Guide to Cosy Homes▲67

   A practical guide on turning a house into a home

   2016 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

5. 5
   Archive 81 - Teaser▲56

   A found footage horror podcast about cities and old gods.

   2016 · podcasts.apple.com · its alternatives →

6. 6
   Evil by Design▲68

   Like Nir Eyal's "Hooked" but with more pictures, and evil.

   2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

7. 7
   House of Leaves▲69

   Layered narration about a house that is bigger on the inside

   2015 · penguinrandomhouse.com · its alternatives →

8. 8
   Ember 101▲68

   A beginners guide to Ember.

   2015 · leanpub.com · its alternatives →

9. 9
   Notes Of Obsession▲66

   Try to survive the night in a creepy modern, Swedish house

   2016 · gamejolt.com · its alternatives →

10. 10
    Cabin Porn▲131

    336 pages of cabins with original stories and photos.

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

11. 11
    Archive 81 - Episode 3 - A Story in Cycles▲54

    It's about exploitation, stories, and an ouroboros

    2016 · podcasts.apple.com · its alternatives →

12. 12
    Monster Crate Club▲59

    Monthly mystery crate for children horror books.

    2016 · monstercrateclub.com · its alternatives →

13. 13
    Magic for Beginners▲53

    A supernatural short story collection written beautifully

    2015 · goodreads.com · its alternatives →

14. 14
    The Thirteenth Tale▲71

    A twisted tale of gothic mystery and family history

    2015 · amazon.co.uk · its alternatives →

15. 15
    The Infinite Monkey Cage Christmas Special▲66

    Discussing Christmas ghost stories, and paranormal science.

    2016 · bbc.co.uk · its alternatives →

16. 16
    Calm, Cool, Collected▲70

    How to demolish stress, master anxiety, and live your life

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

17. 17
    Into the Brambles▲60

    Dark fantasy based on modernized classical myth

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

18. 18
    Bushcraft 101▲54

    A Field Guide to the Art of Wilderness Survival

    2016 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

19. 19
    Whispering Willows▲68

    Indie horror-themed adventure game

    2016 · nightlightinteractive.com · its alternatives →

20. 20
    Story▲83

    The classic guide to the fundamentals of storytelling

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

21. 21
    Lore - 19: Bite marks▲60

    Lore explores the history of scary stories

    2015 · lorepodcast.libsyn.com · its alternatives →

22. 22
    The Circle▲94

    Be Afraid. Be very afraid

    2015 · amazon.co.uk · its alternatives →

23. 23
    Veganomicon▲72

    The ultimate vegan cookbook

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

24. 24
    Waking Up▲71

    A guide to spirituality without religion

    2015 · amazon.com · its alternatives →

Ranked by how close each launch is in meaning, then by votes. Prices were read from each product’s own site when checked and can change. Refine with your own description →